Your local insurance office in Fort Myers.
Real local service from agent Eliecer Rivero — we shop 30+ A-rated carriers to find your lowest rate. Same-day coverage, honest advice, no runaround.
Eliecer Rivero
Eliecer and the team at the South Cleveland Avenue office help Fort Myers families and businesses find honest, affordable coverage — explained clearly, with no pressure. One quick conversation and we shop the market for you.
Bilingual, local, and genuinely on your side. The kind of agent who calls you back when they say they will.
One local office for your whole life
Auto is just the start. We tailor affordable coverage to your home, your ride and your business — quoted in minutes, online or in person.
Auto & Full Coverage
Liability or full coverage with safe-driver, multi-car and homeowner discounts.
Home & Renters
Protect your home or apartment for pennies a day with affordable protection.
SR-22 Filing
Need an SR-22? We file it fast — often the same day — to get you back on the road.
Commercial & More
Commercial auto, motorcycle, boat and notary services — all under one roof.
We shop 30+ A-rated carriers
We're independent — so instead of one company's price, top carriers compete for your business in a single quote.
…and more A-rated companies. Find your best rate ?
Get covered in 3 easy steps
No pressure, no paperwork mountain — just answer a few questions and see your options.
Tell us a little
Your ZIP and a few quick details — online, by phone, or in person on South Cleveland Avenue.
We shop 30+ carriers
Eliecer compares top A-rated companies instantly to find your best fit and every discount.
Pick & save
Choose the coverage you love and get insured the same day. Welcome to the family.
"Thank you very much — I've been with you for a few years already, and the staff who help me are really helpful and nice people."
"This is a great insurance office! Anytime I call with any issues, concerns or problems they go out of their way to help. The agents here are very competent and try to help you, not just take your money. They have superb customer service and treat customers with the utmost respect."
"They are the best. They always help you out with everything you need — any questions or concerns — and they'll help you find the best insurance for your situation."
Visit the Fort Myers office
Estrella Insurance
Fort Myers, FL 33907
Fort Myers insurance questions
How fast can I get a quote at the South Cleveland Avenue office?
Most quotes are ready in minutes — online, by phone at (866) 853-6078, or in person at 11150 S Cleveland Ave #110 — so you can decide quickly and confidently.
Can I get same-day coverage in Fort Myers?
Yes. Auto, renters and motorcycle coverage often start immediately after approval, giving you instant protection.
Do you offer SR-22 filings?
Yes — we file SR-22s for Fort Myers drivers fast, often the same day. Just ask Eliecer and we'll walk you through it.
Will you help me find every discount?
Absolutely. Because we compare 30+ carriers, we apply every discount you qualify for to get the cheapest possible rate for your situation.
¿Hablan español?
¡Claro que sí! Nuestro equipo es bilingüe y le ayuda a cotizar y ahorrar en su seguro en español o en inglés.
Ready to save with your local Fort Myers office?
Get a free quote with Eliecer and the team at Estrella Insurance — online in about 2 minutes, or call us right now.
Home
Find an Agent
Contact Us
About Us
Online Support
Make a Payment
Franchising
Newsletters